![]() |
Kriya Study 1 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
"These days I have not been teaching Kriya to anyone because once receiving Kriya no one practices as intensely as is recommended" - Keshabananda, ca. 1942 |
Kriya Mysteries: A Scriptural Exegesis
The famous guru Paramahansa Yogananda (1893-1952) (qv) taught and changed kriya-yoga in the United States for thirty years and wrote an influential autobiography where he talks for kriya yoga and tell tall tales connected to gurus of his guru line. His "father guru" was Swami Sri Yukteswar (1855-36). His "grandfather guru" was Shyama Lahiri. His "great grandfather guru" is called deathless Babaji. In addition to these four gurus of India Yogananda claims Krishna and Jesus to be among the gurus of his fellowship too. There is at least one problem right there. Also, Babaji tells of and Yogananda seeks support for kriya from many well-known, respected scriptures that seldom or never appear to refer to the specific kriya-yoga teachings at all. Their scriptural props are what we go into in the following. Guru assertions and scriptural commentaries are given for the purpose of clarification. Kriya in the GitaIn his Autobiography, Yogananda writes that "Kriya is an ancient science", and that Lahiri Mahasaya received it from Babaji, who rediscovered, clarified, and renamed the technique Kriya Yoga."The Kriya Yoga that I am giving to the world through you in this nineteenth century, is a revival of the same science that Krishna gave millenniums ago to Arjuna; and that was later known to Patanjali and Christ, and to St. John, St. Paul, and other disciples," Babaji told Lahiri Mahasaya. Yogananda thinks Kriya Yoga is twice referred to in the Bhagavad-Gita. [4:29; 4:1-2.] The passages read in Sivananda's translation, which is on-line on the site: The Blessed Lord said:On what grounds does Yogananda claim the Gita talks of kriya yoga in these three sutras (aphorisms, "threads of thought")? The ancient yoga Krishna divulges to his bowman Arjuna in verse three that an ancient, secret yoga "has been today taught to you by me." "Earlier", that suggests earlier than in chapter four, or what? Thus, at least two of the sutras that Yogananda uses to underpin his message, do not prove anything about the specific kriya yoga the guru taught. The connection between the first two verses of chapter four and kriya yoga appears to give no evidence. It is not for us to dig up the evidence here, for the burden of proof rests on Yogananda and his line. The scriptural documentation for kriya that is furnished in Babaji's dynasty is far from convincing. Some may say it is not there. Our task is not to fall victim to hearsay. What we can assess is that many big words of Yogananda do not appear to have any substantial hold, despite the fact that the Yogananda line of gurus hold more or less tenaciously that in the Bhagavad Gita (The Lord's Song) Krishna tells of kriya yoga methods or similar techniques that mankind lost. Consider that the verses above are Yogananda's main evidence. As evidence it is not good enough. His use of the verses shows dogmatic insistence. You could need to be outside the sect to feel allowed to see it.
The Gita Survey
What kind of kriya evidence is in the Bhagavad Gita's previous chapters, then? We suggest it is meagre if not absent.Some vital background information on the Gita is needed to see it in a better light than an obscure light: The Bhagavad Gita (Song of the Lord) is teaching poetry, and part of a longer poem. It is poetry. Poetry may or may not give good proof. The Gita constitute the sections 25-42 in Bhisma Parva (Book 6), of the Mahabharata poem. The teachings of the Gita in it are delivered on the brink of war, in a tragic scene where the bowman Arjuna and his charioteer Krishna survey two armies that are arrayed against one another. Standing between these two armies that are ready to combat one another, Krishna and Arjuna start talking about what is best in life. The initially despondent bowman Arjuna never cries, "This is not the time or place for deep subjects! Any moment now cruel fighting begins!" He does not refuse Krishna to make the moments bright. [Mmw] Think for yourself. [MORE] Kriya in PatanjaliYogananda's First Shot compared to those of other commentatorsYogananda assesses that Kriya Yoga is mentioned twice by the ancient sage Patanjali, a forefront exponent of yoga. In Patanjali's Yoga Sutras we find: "Kriya Yoga consists of body discipline, mental control, and meditating on Aum " [2:1].In his autobiography Yogananda adds, "In using the words Kriya Yoga, Patanjali was referring either to the technique later taught by Babaji or to one very similar. That Patanjali was mentioning a definite technique of life-force control is proved by his aphorism in Yoga Sutras 2:49 [Ay Ch 26, n 6] First, there are many different methods that suit Patanjali's sutra 2:49. There is more on that issue below. Second, question the sooner the better how Yogananda can say that Patanjali refers to a specific set of yoga methods - methods that appeared later than Patanjali - by tapah-svadhyayeshvara-pranidhanani kriya-yogah. The Sanskrit line may be taken to mean: "Tapas (austerity or sacrifice as self-discipline), Svadhyaya (self-study, traditionally understood as study with or without delicate repetition of fit mantras or learning good books) and Isvara-pranidhana (pious attention within to Ishwara - God of Light) constitute Kriya-yoga (Activity Yoga) [2:1]." The translators and commentators Pranabhananda and Isherwood say: "Having devoted the first chapter of his aphorisms to the aims of yoga, Patanjali now begins a chapter on its practice. These preliminary steps toward yoga are known collectively as kriya-yoga, which means literally "work toward yoga."" [Yof 67] We have no knowledge of any ancient scriptural evidence that the "kriya" word in the Sanskrit sutra here, refers to the particular methods that Babaji named kriya yoga as late as in 1861. That date appears to be over two thousand years after most of Patanjali's Yoga Sutras handbook was written. Besides, the word 'kriya' is taken to mean such as practice, actions, and work in the old Sanskrit word. Yogananda explains it in the opening lines of chapter 26 of his autobiography: "The Sanskrit root of kriya is kri, to do, to act and react; the same root is found in the word karma." [Ay ch 26]. Armed with this knowledge you can translate Patanjali 2:1 differently from Yogananda. Many translators do that. Our shot at it here is: "Proper austerity, self-study, and turning one's devotion within to see Bright Light, is the yoga to do," says Patanjali quite accurately.
Yogananda's second shot compared to shots of othersYogananda goes on: "Patanjali refers a second time to the Kriya technique or life-force control thus: "Liberation can be attained by that pranayama which is accomplished by disjoining the course of inspiration and expiration."" [Yoga Sutras 2.49]The Sanskrit of the Yoga Sutras verse 2:41 runs like this in one transliteration: tasmin sati svasa-prasvasayor gati-viccedah pranayamah. Hariharananda writes: "That (Asana) having been perfected, regulation of the flow of inhalation and exhalation is Pranayama (breath control)." "After mastering posture, one must practice control of the prana (pranayama) by stopping the motions of inhalation and exhalation," write Pranabhananda and Christopher Isherwood. [Yof] Pranayama teachingsPatanjali writes of pranayama. Yogananda says passages in Patanjali Yoga Sutras refer to kriya yoga. He is in that sort of "business". Advocating and finding scriptural props for kriya yoga may colour the associations of some writers. But the medley below suggests there are other and more general ways of understanding the sutra:"Regulating" "regulation of breath" "Control of the breath, cutting off of the motion of in-breath and out-breath" "Stopping breathing in and out" "Restraining the breathing in and out" "Regulation of breath (Pranayama) is the stoppage of the inspiratory and expiratory movements (of breath) which follows, when that has been secured" Raghanath Iyer understands this to mean that "pranayama is the regulation of breath, the restraint of inhalation and exhalation." B. K. S. Iyengar writes "Pranayama is the regulation of the incoming and outgoing flow of breath with retention." Vital elements of pranayama are inhaling and exhaling and having the flow of breath dwindle and pause, that is, stop a bit by itself too. Patanjali's terse or obscure sutra leaves room for various understandings of how to do it, and there are several pranayama methods attuned to the gist of Patanjali here, along with teachings and warnings. "The breath may be stopped externally, or internally, or checked in mid-motion, and regulated according to place, time and a fixed number of moments, so that the stoppage is either protracted or brief," write Pranabhananda and Isherwood, and also that "prana means the vital energy by which we live". Pranabhananda and Isherwood also add about prana that "this [vital] energy is renewed by breathing, prana may sometimes be translated as "breath"; but the word has a much broader reference". "All the powers of the body . . . and the mind are regarded as expressions of the force of prana." Prana is many old texts is understood as a "primal energy". [Yof 2:50, comments. p 112] The sutras 49, 50 and 51 all allude to regulation of the breath. Sutra 51 alludes to an interconnection between mind and breathing: Interiorising the mind deeply may affect the breathing. Sleep modifies the breathing too. Control of the prana through exercises, or after reached a certain stage of spiritual development, the breathing may cease of its own accord for many seconds while he is deeply absorbed. This is natural. [Yof 112-17, passim]
In yoga literature prana is associated with bhutas, elements, and with said centres of vital energy in the subtle spine, which is called the sushumna nadi, which is a vessel for such energies. When the mind reaches the seventh centre of the sushumna (chakra, wheel, or padma, lotus) at the top of the head by backing up the "subtle energy trek" through the sushumna, yoga samadhi is attained. One becomes a knower of Brahman [God], united with Brahman.
Breathe in deeply.
This exercise can be continued. You may try to breathe through the nostrils only or the nostrils and the mouth at the same time. You do as you find best - do not get tense. Do not overdo anything or go too far. Questions and AnswersQ. Does Patanjali talk of kriya yoga, or does he use the Sanskrit word kriya in a general meaning?A. He does use "kriya(h)". Some translators translate it into "kriya yoga", most others do not, as you can see. To almost all translators it is something like "the yoga to do", that is a general way of speaking, not mentioning any specific method by the term 'kriya'.
Q. How many times do the word "kriya" appear in Patanjali's Yoga Sutras?
Q. How do different translators deal with the term?
Q. What is the fit translation?
Q. On what grounds is it said that Babaji's kriya yoga is referred to in the Yoga Sutras? More EvidenceMany translations carry a bias, or a spin, somehow. Translations reflect the stands and cultures and understanding of the translators more or less. Some translations are better, more cultured, and more reliable than others. If you do not know who they are, there are some lax rules of the thumb:The translator's renown can be studied. Books by well educated people and published by university publishers could be good, as these agents have standards and depend on repute. Translations that appear on the Internet are of mixed quality. We have not detected any dandy way of dealing with all sorts of Internet-published works. Some may be very good, and by reputed experts in their fields and the like, also with publishers of a good reputation. Others may or may not be up to similar or better standards. That is where the problem lies. Being "good birds to eat" they may still lack the "feathers" we have talked of, the "feathers" to know the birds by. So some publications on the Internet may not be up to best standards of today. The same may be said of quite old books that are republished on the Internet: Even thought they were first published by what once was thought of as eminent writers and publishers, much of them may not be actual (in line with current interests and understandings), and factual (based on facts) well enough as judged by today's standards and knowledge. Many famous books might need to be updated. Textbook writers may experience it almost yearly. Parts of the experience is a little like a joke about the couple Ole and Lena: Someone asks: "You two have been married over 50 years - tell me, do you still make love?" Old male voice: "Sure we make love - almost every day." "Really? Almost every day?" "That's right. Almost on Monday, almost on Tuesday, almost on Wednesday . . ." In older works the fit standard of today may be almost there . . . And parts may be fine too, and that should be acknowledged. Hence, sifting works with a view to quality can be rather tough and laborous at times, but we have hinted at "what and who" to rely on in gross outline, in case you need it to be told. It is a help. We have looked into seven translations and a couple of Sanskrit transliterations for this study. The Sanskrit word 'kriya" appears in four places of the whole Patanjali work. They are verses 1, 2, 18, and 36 of chapter 2. Raghavan Iyer brings you the Sanskrittapah-svadhyayeshvara-pranidhanani kriya-yogah Austerity, self-study and devoted self-surrender to the Lord constitute the practice of yoga. [2:1]- Raghavan Iyer. xx. Theosophy Library Online, 1987. Swami Hariharananda of Yogananda's lineHariharananda (dead 2002) calls the second chapter "On practice".Tapas (austerity or sturdy self-discipline -mental, moral and physical), Svadhyaya (repetition of sacred Mantras or study of sacred literature) and Isvara-pranidhana (complete surrender to God) are Kriya-yoga (Yoga in the form of action). [2:1]- Swami Hariharananda. Yoga Philosophy of Patanjali. Calcutta: Calcutta University Press, ?? Shyama Lahiri's VersionShyama Lahiri (1828-95) basically interprets the Yoga Sutras and many other works in the light of kriya. That seems all right as long as what he does is made clear: He applies kriya yoga teachings to other works.On the other hand, to say that a dim, greatly forgotten kriya is shown in top prestigious works of Hinduism, like the Bhagavad Gita and Patanjali Yoga Sutras, looks like making use of obscure stanzas much like square holes for round pegs. Many old statements are tersely obscure, and allow for several interpretations. But the best is to side with expert translators in the matter. If they are biased - Yogananda definitely is - their bias should not be wrong, offensive or propagandistic. Solid translations require background knowledge and much else. Take a look at how knowing how to interpret texts can give much help [LINK]. Now for three different versions of Shyama Lahiri's work on the Yoga Sutras. The translations differ, so we bring all three: The first Yoganiketan text (A.1); the second Yoganiketan text (A.2); and the "San Diego text" (B). A.1Now the instructions shall be imparted on how to practice yoga. These instructions are relative to the Guru. A.2 Six Years Later
This Kriya Yoga is the method for bringing about samadhi and for destroying misery. Meaning: continuing to bring about samadhi via Kriya in this way, the afflictions of body and mind are eroded away. Gradually, one can truly hear the Divine Sound, by which, the mind stops imagining any forms. Later, the True Person is attained and there is Subtle Inner Perception (Sikshma Prajna). [Shyama Lahiri's Commentary to Patanjali Yoga Sutras 2:1-2, Yoganiketan text of 2005.] [1. Tapa:] Pranaba, or OM, which is spontaneously heard. [2. Swadhyaya:] The chanting of OM (practicing Omkar Kriyas with a particular Mantra]. [3. Iswarapranidhana:] Holding onto the Self, surrendering all actions to the Self and offering inner Realization - all of which are done by him.
To remove suffering and to attain Samdadhi, Kriya Yoga must be practiced. I die every day - I mean that, brothers - just as surely as I glory over you in Christ Jesus our Lord . . . If the dead are not raised, "Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die." [1 Cor 15:31-32] What you sow does not come to life unless it dies. [1 Cor 15:36] "Where, death, is your victory?" [1 Cor 15:55] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Literature | SECTION | First Page |
CLICK on 'Literature' for the references of about 2000
works.
ANNOTATIONS: Code letters (acronyms and initial words) in square brackets in the text refer to works. Click on 'Literature' to see examples. Page references are put right after code
letters. And the abbreviation cf. means "compare". [MORE].
SITE SEARCH: The 'Search' link gives access to dictionaries and more.
REFER: Prefer the standard 'location address' on top of the page(s).
PILOTING: Note the clickable text links on top of the page. [MORE]
DISCLAIMER: Two disclaimers intertwine: [A] [B]
© 20002006, Tormod Kinnes. All rights reserved October 2006.